Hoyts Pty Ltd v Burns

JurisdictionAustralia Federal only
CourtHigh Court (Australia)
JudgeMcHugh,Gummow,Hayne,Callinan JJ,Kirby J
Judgment Date09 October 2003
Neutral Citation2003-1009 HCA A,[2003] HCA 61
Docket NumberS450/2002
Date09 October 2003

[2003] HCA 61

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

McHugh, Gummow, Kirby, Hayne and Callinan JJ

S450/2002

Hoyts Pty Limited
Appellant
and
Diane Burns
Respondent
Representation:

D F Jackson QC with A J McInerney for the appellant (instructed by Herbert Geer & Rundle)

B W Walker SC with P A Regattieri for the respondent (instructed by R J Rimes)

Negligence — Causation — Failure to warn customers that cinema seats retracted automatically — Respondent injured attempting to sit on a retracted seat — Whether Court of Appeal erred in interfering in primary judge's finding that warning sign would not have altered respondent's conduct.

Appeal — Rehearing before Court of Appeal — Relevance of credibility findings — Whether primary judge's conclusion based upon assessment of credibility of party — Whether Court of Appeal erred in disturbing such conclusion — Whether Court of Appeal omitted to find error before substituting its own conclusion on the evidence.

ORDER

1. Appeal allowed with costs.

2. Set aside the orders of the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of New South Wales made on 8 February 2002 and, in lieu thereof, order that the appeal to that Court be dismissed.

1

McHugh, Gummow, Hayne and Callinan JJ. This appeal raises no difficult question of principle. It requires this Court to decide whether an intermediate Court of Appeal was justified in reversing orthodox and carefully considered findings of fact and credibility by a trial judge.

The facts
2

The appellant owns and exhibits films at the Hoyts Cinema Complex at Bankstown in Sydney. The respondent, who was working as a teacher's aide specializing in disabled children, attended the appellant's cinema complex on 17 March 1997. She was then aged about 47. She was accompanied by five adults and eight disabled young children. Her particular responsibility was Joshua, a boy of four years of age who could crawl very quickly but still required a wheelchair.

3

The respondent did not go to the cinema regularly. She had never been to the Bankstown complex before. Indeed, by 17 March 1997 she had not been inside a picture theatre for many years.

4

Neither outside or inside the theatre nor on the screen at any time was there exhibited a sign referring in any way to the seats in the theatre.

5

The group of which the respondent was a member went down an aisle of the particular theatre where the film that they wished to see was being shown. They seated themselves in the front row. The lights of the theatre were on when the respondent entered.

6

Because each seat automatically rose to rest at an angle of 70 degrees to the floor when there was no weight upon it, the respondent's seat must have been in an upright position immediately before she sat down on it. In order to sit upon it she must have exerted force of some kind upon it, either by pushing it or sitting down on it, to bring it to a position generally parallel to the floor.

7

When the respondent seated herself, Joshua was in his wheelchair just to the right in front of her. After a time the lights darkened and the film started. Some light was emitted from the screen. Joshua became very agitated. He began to scream. The respondent thought that if he were taken out of his wheelchair he might calm down. As soon as the respondent placed him on the floor he quickly crawled away from her. She left her seat to retrieve him. He was screaming and kicking and apparently continued to do so as she attempted to resume her seat which had of course by then become upright again. This is how the respondent accounted for what followed:

‘Well, I had hold of him with my right arm, felt for what I thought was the seat, I sat down, I moved my arm like this and held him and when I sat down there wasn't any seat there but by the time I realised I had gone past the point of no return I couldn't stand up. … I hit the metal bar and fell forward. … The very bottom of my spine, the tailbone.’

8

The respondent suffered injuries as a result of the events which have just been described.

The trial
9

The respondent brought proceedings in the New South Wales District Court against the appellant for damages for negligence. The particulars that she alleged, and which involve what in this Court remain live issues, were that the appellant was negligent in failing to warn the respondent of the dangers from seats folding up when no weight was upon them and in failing to warn the respondent that, when looking after disabled children, her seat would rise should she need to leave the seat for any reason.

10

The action was heard by Gibb DCJ in February 2001. Each of the parties engaged an expert whose written report was received in evidence. Neither of the experts gave oral evidence.

11

The respondent's expert, Dr Emerson, an engineer, described himself as a specialist in accident analysis. In addition to asserting a number of argumentative matters he said that projecting obstructions, the hinged steel brackets which supported the seats, could have been eliminated by a better engineering design. It was not necessary for the brackets to be constructed so as to project 60 mm from the base of the seat: flat brackets ‘located closer to the underneath section of the chair without the need to project so far’ would have sufficed. He also said that if this form of seating were to be used, the metal brackets should be covered with high density rubber or foam. Alternatively, the seats could be fixed as was the situation in a number of other theatres. He also suggested the provision of a sign to indicate to patrons that the seats had an automatic return to the upright position.

12

The appellant's expert, Mr Eager, also an engineer, was of a quite different opinion. He was unaware of any Australian Standard covering theatre seating design. The installation of seats of the kind in use at Bankstown was a frequent occurrence. It had the advantage of allowing easier access by patrons and cleaners. The theatre complex at Bankstown had been in operation for about 10 years. It had a seating capacity of more than 2,400 people. No other previous incident of the kind which the respondent alleged to have occurred had been recorded.

13

Notwithstanding that the respondent had alleged as a particular of negligence a failure to warn, the respondent initially gave no evidence of the effect that any warning had it been given might have had upon her. At the close of the appellant's case the respondent applied for leave to adduce further evidence to repair this omission. The application was opposed but over objection the primary judge allowed evidence as follows to be given:

‘[Counsel for the respondent]: Q. If you had been made aware by the way of signs as you came into the theatre, or a sign placed in front of your feet where you sat in the front row, or by a warning sign on the screen that these seats would retract and go back to an upright position by that, when you picked up the child and went back to the seat what would you have done in relation to placing yourself on that seat?

…

[A.] Had there been signs there to warn me I would have been aware that the seat would retract and I would have made sure that the seat was completely down and held it down before I sat down.

[Counsel]: That's the evidence of the [respondent], your Honour, on this position.

CROSS-EXAMINATION

[Counsel for the appellant]: Q. Mrs Burns, to be frank you don't know what your reaction would have been if there were signs, do you?

A. I would have taken notice of the signs, had there been signs, and I would have been aware more aware to make sure, would have been aware to make sure that the seat, I had to pull the seat to sit down, yes.

Q. You see, you did have to pull the seat to sit down, didn't you?

A. I didn't know that at that time.

Q. Well, I suggest to you that you did, because you had to pull the seat down to sit on it, did you not?

A. That was in the first instance.

Q. And it was under pressure that you pulled it down?

A. I actually sat at the same time as I pulled the seat down.

Q. You knew that you had to put pressure on the seat from the time you started to push it down to be able to sit on it?

A. No, I was not aware of that at all, I'm sorry.

Q. You see, how can you say now if there were signs in the theatre, that you would become aware of them?

OBJECTION.

HER HONOUR: I think it is a fair question in cross-examination.

[Counsel for the appellant]: Q. How can you say now that if there were signs in the theatre that you would have become aware of them?

A. Because I would have read the signs.

Q. How do you know you would have read them?

A. Well, if there had of been signs on the walls, or on the floor, or on the screen, I would have read the sign. I can only say I would have read the signs.

Q. Do you agree what you are saying is mere speculation about what you would have done?

A. That's very hard. No, I would still say that had there of been signs I would have read them and known that the seat retracted.

Q. You see, you came to the theatre with what you say was a group of highly disabled children, didn't you?

A. That's correct.

Q. And these children needed a fair degree of care, didn't they?

A. They do.

Q. And you had children spread in front of you, between you and the screen, didn't you?

A. I had one to my right and one on a bean bag to my left that was for the other person, yes.

Q. So you don't know, you can't say now that [if] there were signs whether you would have seen them, or not?

A. If the signs were as I came through the door, on the walls or in front of the screen itself, or on the front of the stage, I would have obviously seen them.

Q. How is it so obvious that you would have seen them?

A. For the same way you can see the exit sign which was to my right. There was a sign with lights around it. It was quite noticeable. You...

Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI

Get Started for Free

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex
22 cases
  • Neindorf v Junkovic
    • Australia
    • High Court (Australia)
    • December 8, 2005
    ...572 at 598 [107]. 87 (1986) 7 NSWLR 241 at 246–247. 88 (1991) 173 CLR 33 at 38. 89 As in Watson v George (1953) 89 CLR 409. See also Hoyts Pty Ltd v Burns (2003) 77 ALJR 1934 at 1942 [46]; 201 ALR 470 at 90 Wrongs Act, s 17C(2)(d). 91 Wrongs Act, s 17C(2)(e). 92 Wrongs Act, s 17C(2)(f). 93......
  • Anikin v Sierra
    • Australia
    • High Court (Australia)
    • December 9, 2004
    ...v Berryman (2003) 214 CLR 552; Whisprun Pty Ltd v Dixon (2003) 77 ALJR 1598; 200 ALR 447; Hoyts Pty Ltd v Burns (2003) 77 ALJR 1934; 201 ALR 470. 53Liftronic Pty Ltd v Unver (2001) 75 ALJR 867 at 879 [65]; 179 ALR 321 at 336. 54 (1952) 85 CLR 352. See also Nominal Defendant v Owens (1978) 2......
  • Csr Ltd v Della Maddalena
    • Australia
    • High Court (Australia)
    • February 2, 2006
    ...197 ALR 410 at 413; Whisprun Pty Ltd v Dixon (2003) 77 ALJR 1598 at 1610–1611 [65]–[68]; 200 ALR 447 at 464–465; Hoyts Pty Ltd v Burns (2003) 77 ALJR 1934 at 1942–1944 [49]–[59]; 201 ALR 470 at 481–484; Pledge v Roads and Traffic Authority (2004) 78 ALJR 572 at 581–582 [43]; 205 ALR 56 at ......
  • Commissioner of Main Roads v Jones
    • Australia
    • High Court (Australia)
    • May 25, 2005
    ...MVR 451 at 470. 21 (2002) 37 MVR 451 at 460. 22 (2002) 37 MVR 451 at 461. 23 (2002) 37 MVR 451 at 470–471. 24 cf Hoyts Pty Ltd v Burns (2003) 77 ALJR 1934 at 1939 [24]–[27]; 201 ALR 470 at 476. 25 (2003) 37 MVR 451 at 455. 26 See r 1001(1) of the Road Traffic Code (WA). 27 at the relevant t......
  • Get Started for Free
1 firm's commentaries
1 books & journal articles
  • The Australian High Court and Social Facts: A Content Analysis Study
    • United Kingdom
    • Sage Federal Law Review No. 40-3, September 2012
    • September 1, 2012
    ...(2003) 200 ALR 1 L 2003 Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118 M 2003 Amaca Pty Ltd v NSW (2003) 199 ALR 596 L 2003 Hoyts Pty Ltd v Burns (2003) 201 ALR 470 M 2003 Shorey v PT Ltd (2003) 197 ALR 410 L 2003 Dovuro Pty Ltd v Wilkins (2003) 215 CLR 317 M 2003 Gifford v Strang Patrick Stevedoring Pty L......