ICARUS AND THE EVIDENCE ACT: SECTION 137, PROBATIVE VALUE AND TAKING FORENSIC SCIENCE EVIDENCE 'AT ITS HIGHEST'.

JurisdictionAustralia
Date01 August 2017
AuthorEdmond, Gary

CONTENTS I Introduction: Escaping the Cretans II IMM v The Queen and Determining Probative Value for the Purpose of Section 137 A Too Close to the Sun: Probative Value at Some Imagined 'Highest' B Between the Sun and the Sea: Probative Value among the Dissentients 1 Probative Value at its Actual 'Highest' 2 (Actual) Probative Value C Seeing in the Fog III The Probative Value of Scientific, Medical and Technical Evidence A Determining the Probative Value of Opinions Based on Specialised Knowledge B States of Knowledge and Ignorance C Carried Away with Phaethon: What 'at its Highest' Cannot Mean D Reliability and Credibility and Probative Value E Standing by Itself F Free Flying? Limits on the Jury's Prerogative IV Seeing through Heydon's Fog: Interpreting Images after Honeysett A The Opinion of a Passport Officer B Can Trial Safeguards Identify Problems and Convey Them to Jurors? V 'Danger of Unfair Prejudice to the Defendant' and the Balancing Exercise A The Danger of Unfair Prejudice B The Balancing Exercise and Mitigation of the Risk VI Re-Imagining Probative Value for Opinions Based on Specialised Knowledge I INTRODUCTION: ESCAPING THE CRETANS

In a criminal proceeding, the court must refuse to admit evidence adduced by the prosecutor if its probative value is outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice to the defendant. (1) '[P]robative value' of evidence means the extent to which the evidence could rationally affect the assessment of the probability of the existence of a fact in issue. (2) In the classical myth, Icarus enjoyed the freedom flight afforded. Inattentive to knowledgeable admonition, he pushed his new-found liberty, falling 'in love with the sky'. (3) Icarus flew too close to the sun. Wax securing the feathers on the wings crafted by his father melted and he fell catastrophically. The myth of Icarus offers a salutary lesson about the value of attending to knowledge; in the myth, the advice of Icarus' father. Daedalus warned his son against complacency (flying too low) and hubris (flying too high). This article endeavours to explain the related dangers of disregarding reliability and soaring unrestrained when assessing the probative value of opinions based on specialised knowledge in criminal proceedings. (4)

With the exception of DNA profiling, Australian courts have been remarkably resistant to engaging with the reliability of scientific, medical and technical evidence adduced by prosecutors in criminal proceedings. (5) No Australian court requires proponents of opinions purportedly based on specialised knowledge to provide evidence of the underlying procedure's validity (ie that is actually works), its level of error, or the proficiency of the 'expert'. (6) This is unfortunate because the appropriate mechanism for assessment of reliability (and validity) exists in s 79(1), which provides that

[i]f a person has specialised knowledge based on the person's training, study or experience, the opinion rule does not apply to evidence of the person's opinion that is completely or substantially based on that knowledge. (7) That contention finds support in Honeysett v The Queen where the High Court unanimously endorsed the following definitions of 'knowledge, though without addressing the reliability issue:

The Macquarie Dictionary defines 'knowledge' as 'acquaintance with facts, truths, or principles, as from study or investigation' (emphasis added) and it is in this sense that it is used in s 79(1). The concept is captured in Blackmun J's formulation in Daubert v Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals Inc: 'the word "knowledge" connotes more than subjective belief or unsupported speculation ... [It] applies to any body of known facts or to any body of ideas inferred from such facts or accepted as truths on good grounds.' (8) It bears noting that in Daubert the Supreme Court of the United States interpreted the term 'knowledge', from the phrase 'scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge' in r 702 of the Federal Rules of Evidence, to require federal judges to attend to validity and reliability. (9) This approach to 'scientific knowledge' was extended to 'technical, or other specialized knowledge' in Kumho Tire Co Ltd v Carmichael and eventually led to revision of the Federal Rules of Evidence in 2000 and 2011. (10) Subsequently, the Supreme Court of Canada--following the US lead--interpreted its common law to require trial judges to consider the reliability of expert opinion evidence in the aftermath of a series of wrongful convictions. (11) More recently, a rules committee chaired by the Lord Chief Justice of England, responding to the thrust of recommendations (and a Bill drafted) by the Law Commission of England and Wales, (12) embedded the need for reliability in the Criminal Procedure Rules 2015 (England and Wales). (13)

With Australian courts reluctant, thus far, to consider reliability as part of s 79(1), (14) the primary protections against the admission and misuse of weak, speculative and unreliable opinion evidence are ss 135 and 137, and judicial warnings. (15) This article explains why judges must attend in their admissibility jurisprudence and practice to reliability--really validity and scientific reliability. (16) Without abandoning the need to consider reliability as part of s 79(1), it responds to IMM v The Queen, where, considering probative value in relation to the admission of tendency and context evidence in a sexual assault prosecution, a bare majority of the High Court insisted that issues of reliability and credibility should play no part in the trial judge's assessment of probative value for the purposes of ss 135 and 137. (17)

In their attempts to determine 'the extent to which' evidence can 'rationally affect the assessment of the probability of the existence of a fact in issue, trial judges cannot avoid issues of reliability and credibility. This article explains why trial judges should consider both the reliability of procedures and the proficiency of the witness when determining the probative value of opinions based on specialised knowledge--so-called 'expert evidence'. (18) When it comes to scientific, medical and technical evidence, there are very few means of gauging probative value (and weight) without determining whether the procedure works, how well and in what conditions, and whether the forensic practitioner is proficient with procedures known to work. (19) Opinions produced using scientific, medical and technical procedures cannot be rationally assessed unless the procedures have been subjected to formal evaluation. Trial safeguards, such as s 137 (and Christie in common law jurisdictions), intended to prevent unfair prejudice to the accused, are rendered impotent when prosecutors and trial judges do not engage with actual probative value derived through formal studies. (20) In such cases, issues of validity and reliability fall to be contested by lawyers and evaluated by laypersons as part of an adversarial proceeding. Our accusatory system--and here we should not overlook the system's heavy reliance on plea (and charge) bargains and the limited resourcing available to most defendants--has not proven capable of consistently identifying and conveying fundamental problems with new procedures (eg facial mapping, voice comparison and forensic gait analysis) let alone the many untested, or insufficiently tested, procedures (eg firearm, shoeprint, tyre, fibre and document comparisons) routinely used by investigators and adduced by prosecutors. (21)

To the extent that trial judges are concerned with the ability of opinion evidence to 'rationally affect the assessment of the probability of the existence of a fact in issue, they must be constrained by the availability of knowledge derived through the formal evaluation of procedures. Whether they like it or not, and regardless of whether they understand the issues, when it comes to the rational determination of the probative value of forensic science evidence, trial judges are dependent on evidence of validity, scientific reliability and proficiency. (22)

In the fraught tradition of Daedalus, this article constitutes a warning. Australian courts must focus attention on the reliability of opinions based on specialised knowledge. Attempts to determine the probative value of scientific, medical and technical evidence without considering reliability risk flying too close to the sun.

II IMM V THE QUEEN AND DETERMINING PROBATIVE VALUE FOR THE PURPOSE OF SECTION 137

The vexed question of how trial judges should approach probative value was recently considered by the High Court in IMM. (23) While IMM was not concerned with scientific, medical or technical evidence, the decision appears set to structure the way s 137 applies to opinions based wholly or substantially on specialised knowledge (admitted via s 79). Rather than repeat the divergent approaches to statute and the common law, this section endeavours to capture what the various judgments require of trial judges.

The basic issue at the centre of IMM was summarised as follows:

Where the tribunal of fact is a jury, is a judge determining probative value required to assume that the jury would find the evidence to be credible and otherwise reliable and to assess, on that assumption, the extent to which the jury could rationally infer from the evidence that a fact in issue is more or less probable? Alternatively, is the judge required to examine whether the jury could rationally find evidence to be credible and otherwise reliable as a step in determining the extent to which the jury could rationally infer from the evidence that the fact in issue is more or less probable? (24) A Too Close to the Sun: Probative Value at Some Imagined 'Highest'

According to French CJ, Kiefel, Bell and Keane JJ (the majority), determining the probative value of evidence for the purposes of ss 97 and 137 requires 'an assessment of the probative value of the evidence tendered'. (25)...

Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI

Get Started for Free

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex

Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial

Transform your legal research with vLex

  • Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform

  • Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues

  • Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options

  • Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions

  • Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms

  • Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations

vLex