John William Suthern v Unilever Australia Ltd
| Jurisdiction | Australian Capital Territory |
| Court | Supreme Court of ACT |
| Judge | Crispin J |
| Judgment Date | 28 September 2007 |
| Docket Number | No. SC 178 of 1999 |
| Date | 28 September 2007 |
[2007] ACTSC 81
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
Crispin J
No. SC 178 of 1999
Counsel for the plaintiff: Mr A J Bartley SC with Mr F Tuscano
Counsel for the defendant: Mr H Shore SC and Mr G Watson SC with Ms K Williams
Anchor Products Ltd v Hedges 26 (1966) 115 CLR 493
Schellenberg v Tunnell Holdings Pty Ltd (2000) 200 CLR 121
Jones v Dunkel (1958) 101 CLR 298
Wyong Shire Council v Shirt (1980) 146 CLR 40
Modbury Triangle Shopping Centre Pty Ltd v Anzil (2000) 205 CLR 254.
Cooper & Ors v Westpac General Insurance Limited [2007] ACTCA 20 (14 September 2007)
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), ss 53(a), 74B
Martindale — The Extra Pharamacopoeia, 26 th Edition (pg 1053) published in 1972
NEGLIGENCE — personal injury claim — plaintiff allegedly suffered poisoning due to ingestion of mercury in ice cream — whether mercury introduced into the ice cream during manufacturing process — evidence of mercury levels in subsequent urine samples suggestive of further ingestions — whether continuing symptoms attributable to initial ingestion — no issue of principle.
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1. Judgment be entered for the plaintiff in the sum of $10,000.
The plaintiff claims damages for personal injuries allegedly sustained as a result of the ingestion of mercury contained in ice cream that he ate on 13 and 14 June 1996.
He gave evidence that his former wife, Mrs Pilar Gee, had bought a tub of Streets Blue Ribbon ice cream from the Cannon's Superbarn store at Erindale in the ACT on 12 June 1996. He opened it on the following evening and served some onto plates for himself and his two children but did not at that time notice anything unusual about the ice cream. On the evening of 14 June, the plaintiff again served ice cream for himself and his children. In the course of doing so, he ate two spoonfuls of ice cream taken directly from the tub. He then noticed a silver ball in the bottom of the tub and, when he attempted to remove it, noticed it break into two smaller balls. He then examined the ice cream and saw that there were grey streaks in the side from which he had been taking the scoops. He also noticed tiny dots of what appeared to be mercury.
He spoke to his wife about what he had seen, telephoned the Poisons Information Service and then had a further conversation with a friend who was a police officer and whom he knew had undertaken a course in occupational health and safety. In response to his advice, the plaintiff and his wife went to the Canberra Hospital where the ice cream was taken from him and x-rayed. The police were called and the attending officers also inspected the ice cream.
Subsequent tests confirmed that it contained mercury. The plaintiff was also x-rayed and the images revealed small quantities of a substance presumed to be mercury in his abdomen. He was given laxatives and invited to return to the hospital later.
He did not immediately experience any adverse symptoms other than cramping and this may have been attributable to the laxatives. However, as time passed he began to develop a range of unpleasant symptoms that became progressively more disabling. He claims that these were caused by the ingestion of the mercury.
The plaintiff alleges that his injuries and disabilities are attributable to a breach of the duty of care that the defendant owed to him at common law and/or breaches of s 53(a) and 74B of the Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth).
The plaintiff's case on negligence is relatively straightforward. Mrs Gee noticed nothing unusual about the tub of ice cream when she purchased it, and the plaintiff saw nothing unusual about the appearance of the ice cream itself when he removed the lid. The defendant did not receive any communication suggestive of extortion and there is no other reason to suppose that anyone may have tampered with the container or its contents after it had left the factory. Hence, it is a reasonable inference that the mercury was inserted into the ice cream at some stage during the processes of manufacture or packaging. The insertion was unexplained, it occurred whilst all of the relevant circumstances were within the defendant's control and it was an occurrence of a kind that would not ordinarily occur without negligence. Accordingly, he maintains, negligence on the part of the defendant could be inferred by the application of the principle, res ipsa loquitur.
This principle is not a distinct rule of law but an application of an inferential reasoning process from which negligence may be inferred. As the High Court of Australia observed in Anchor Products Ltd v Hedges 26 (1966) 115 CLR 493 at 500, and the more recent case of Schellenberg v Tunnell Holdings Pty Ltd (2000) 200 CLR 121 at 133, the burden of proof remains upon the plaintiff. Hence, even if grounds for the application of the principle are established, it remains necessary for the Court to determine whether the burden of proof has been discharged. As Windeyer J determined in Anchor Products v Hedges at 500:
To say that an act speaks for itself does not mean that if no evidence is given for the defendant the plaintiff is entitled in law to a verdict in his favour. The occurrence speaks of negligence, but how clearly and convincingly it speaks depends upon its circumstances. It is evidence from which an inference of negligence may be drawn: it does not mean that this inference must necessarily be drawn, although in some cases it may be evidence so cogent and compelling that any other conclusion would be perverse as Du Parcq L.J. pointed out in Easson v London and North Eastern Railway Co [1944] 1 KB 421 at 425. But always the question whether the plaintiff has discharged the burden of proving his case depends upon the effect of the whole of the evidence given in the case, including such inference as may be drawn from the happening of the accident, if its cause remains unexplained.
In the present case, the plaintiff contends that the occurrence is one that provides compelling evidence of negligence on the part of the defendant.
At an early stage in the proceedings, counsel for the defendant appeared to suggest that the plaintiff may have put mercury into the ice cream himself and knowingly ingested it with a view to providing an apparent basis for a fraudulent claim. This suggestion was not pressed by Mr Watson SC, who later appeared for the defendant with Ms Williams, and I would in any event have rejected it.
Mr Watson did, however, submit that the mercury may have got into the ice cream after it had left the factory. He maintained that it could have been attributable to an act of sabotage within the supermarket or that it could have been inserted deliberately or accidentally whilst the ice cream was in the plaintiff's home. Neither Mrs Gee nor the plaintiff relied or could reasonably have relied upon the skill or judgment of the defendant to prevent the subsequent contamination of the ice cream in any such manner.
The defendant provided evidence, in sworn answers to the plaintiff's interrogatories, that the relevant tub of ice cream had been one of 21,420 produced in a production run between 8.30 pm on 3 May 1996 and 6.50 am on 4 May 1996. Neither the defendant nor the Australian Federal Police received any other complaint of mercury in stock produced in that production run. The defendant tested samples from production runs before and after that run but found no similar problem. The defendant also dismantled and inspected the pasteuriser for signs of mercury but found none. An analysis of burn-on material removed from the pasteuriser showed that there was less than 0.01mg/kg mercury present. The defendant then proceeded to interview 29 staff members who had worked on the relevant production run. They were unable to identify any event that may have been responsible for the introduction of mercury into any of the ice cream. The defendant recalled the product in the ACT, recovering 4,321 containers of ice cream, none of which were found to contain mercury. It also withdrew ice cream produced in that production run from points of sale in other states. It maintained that thermometers were not used in the production of the ice cream but only in its research laboratory.
Staff members were asked to complete a questionnaire which included the question ‘Given that there were small beads of mercury in two distinct spots in the 2L tub of Blue Ribbon, how do you think that the mercury could have got there’? Most of the responses were largely speculative. Some expressed the opinion that it would not have entered the ice cream in the factory whilst others clearly thought that it had. One employee attributed it to the packaging process and added ‘dirt, plastic, hair, dead and alive spiders have been found in the packaging before’.
The defendant also relied on evidence from Professor Hambley who had examined and tested the contents of the remaining ice cream and the relevant tub on 23 October 2000. He also examined x-rays of the tub. He said that the particles of mercury appeared to be distributed only across the irregular surface of the ice cream and were not in the body of it. It was suggested that this demonstrated that the mercury had been added to the ice cream after it had already become frozen.
On the other hand, the evidence of the plaintiff and Mrs Gee of their observations of the ice cream received some support from the hospital notes taken on 14 June 1996 which recorded that ‘mercury … was speckled throughout the tub of ice cream’. The plaintiff said that the doctors who looked at it had been ‘picking pieces out of it’ and had expressed the opinion that it was mercury.
More than four years had obviously elapsed before Professor...
Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeUnlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Start Your 7-day Trial
-
Autonomy and the Law of the Faster Horse: In Response to the Adoption of Autonomous Vehicles, What Aspects of the Australian and Irish Legal Liability Frameworks Require Reform?
...Frank’s Rental (1979) 10 CCLT 306; Thomas v Foreshore Marine Exhaust Systems Pty Ltd [2005] NSWCA 451; Suthern v Unilever Australia Ltd [2007] ACTSC 81. Mele (n 148) connor hogg autonomous technologies and their creators to protect the general public.157 They are set out as follows:158 1. A......